Gas Heat Vs. Electric Heat: Differences, Pros And Cons

Author Image

By Kyle Schurman

Updated: Jun 20, 2024

8 min read

Gas Heat
AI Generated Image: Heaven Gables

Table of Content

    Gas heating systems can utilize either natural gas or propane with simple adjustments. Both fuels are collectively referred to as - Gas. Opting for natural gas heating in your home offers safety, reliability, and affordability. Natural gas furnaces emit minimal pollutants, ensuring safety, while regulatory oversight enhances accountability.

    They provide consistent warmth even during power outages, thanks to direct fuel delivery and efficient performance. With lower fuel costs and extended lifespan, natural gas heating proves to be a financially sensible choice for homeowners.

    Exploring Heating Solutions

    Gas Heating Options
    AI Generated Image: Heaven Gables

    Forced Air Gas Furnaces

    Forced-air gas furnaces, commonly found in American single-family homes, offer high efficiency. They draw in cool air and distribute warm filtered air through registers, although some homes may lack sufficient return registers.

    Problems arise when interior doors are closed, leading to pressure imbalances and increased air leakage. Transfer grilles or jump ducts can alleviate these issues, particularly with central returns. Many forced-air duct systems suffer from significant air leaks, especially in unconditioned spaces like crawl spaces.

    Hot-water, Hydronic, and Steam Systems

    Hot-water or hydronic heating systems circulate boiler-heated water through various means, offering slightly more expensive but comfortable radiant heat. They are popular in cold climates, while hot air systems are preferred in milder climates for their dual heating and cooling capabilities.

    Steam systems, less efficient than hot water, were among the first central heating systems, often utilizing non-insulated steam pipes prone to heat loss. Pipe insulation in these areas is recommended for efficiency.

    Comfort of Localized Space Heating Systems

    Localized space heating supplements central systems, offering efficiency advantages without duct or pipe losses. Space heaters, whether wall-mounted, freestanding, or portable, are useful for heating specific areas like hard-to-heat rooms or new additions, providing comfort and energy savings, especially for the elderly or sensitive individuals.

    Gas Power Heating Systems

    Gas Power Heating Systems
    AI Generated Image: Heaven Gables

    A forced-air furnace powered by gas operates similarly to a central electric furnace, utilizing a control circuit to monitor room temperature and a fan to distribute heated air. Typically installed in a house's basement or space available, the furnace activates when the main thermostat senses a temperature decrease, allowing the gas valve to open and ignite the gas in the heat exchanger.

    Concerns and Dependability of Gas Heating

    Natural gas heating is widely dependable as it is readily available in many areas, unlike oil or propane, which require delivery. Additionally, some gas heating systems can function during power outages, ensuring heating even when electricity is unavailable. Natural gas combustion produces less air pollution compared to burning coal or petroleum products, although it remains a non-renewable fuel source. Thus, while not the most sustainable option, environmentally conscious homeowners may find comfort in selecting a cleaner fossil fuel.

    The Operation of Central Gas Heating Systems

    Blue Flame Natural Gas Heater
    Available on Amazon 🔗

    Heating

    Central heating derives its energy from various sources, including solid fuels like wood, water/steam, petroleum, electricity, heat pumps, and natural gasses. Electric and gas heating are the most common types due to their ease of maintenance. Gas heaters utilize natural gasses, burning them to produce heat, resulting in higher temperatures compared to other systems.

    Comfort

    Central gas heating systems utilize natural gas to warm homes, offering comfort, convenience, reliability and efficiency. Natural gas heat feels warmer than that from a conventional central system, with forced air systems typically emitting air at 120 to 140 degrees, whereas central systems only reach 85-95 degrees, below the human body's average temperature of 98.6 degrees.

    Functionality

    The forced air system, the predominant type of gas heating, employs a natural gas burner to warm air. Cool air is drawn into the system, heated by a heat exchanger, and propelled through ducts by a blower or fan. Concerns about gas heating emissions are mitigated by wall vents that expel fumes outdoors, eliminating the need for a chimney.

    Boiler

    Water-based systems utilize gas boilers to heat homes, with the boiler serving as a critical component. It continuously receives a supply of natural gas to create hot water or steam circulated through pipes to radiators, floor systems, or baseboard units. Radiators operate in binary mode, either fully on or off, depending on the presence of hot water flow.

    Installation of Central Gas Heating Systems

    Rinnai i120SN Central Gas Heating System
    Available on Amazon 🔗

    Initiating

    Central heating systems are a popular choice for home heating due to their efficiency in heating entire homes through ducts.

    The installation of a central heating system involves setting up a gas furnace to heat air passing over a heat exchanger and a duct system for distributing the heated air. This process is intensive and includes selecting the appropriate heating system and hiring a local HVAC company for installation.

    Assessment

    Once you have chosen your system, you will schedule an appointment for an HVAC technician to assess your space and determine the furnace size and ductwork requirements.

    Ductwork

    Ductwork installation begins by opening walls to install round pipes connected to a network with vents. This step typically takes one to two days and requires durable duct material to prevent leaks. The furnace is then connected to gas and electrical wiring, with the installation crew ensuring proper connections and setting up a condensate drain to remove condensation that can be generated by the furnace.

    After double-checking and cleaning up, the installation team will turn on the furnace, allowing you to enjoy your new central gas heating system.

    Cost Efficiency and Impact

    Gas heating tends to be more economical than electric heating, resulting in homeowners saving an average of sixty percent. Nonetheless, the possibilities of natural gas expenses, influenced by geopolitical tensions and supply instability, could potentially change this advantage over time. Despite being less expensive, gas heating can lead to poor air quality due to the release of particles and allergens during combustion. Electric heating, while more stable and unaffected by external factors, is generally pricier.

    Advantages of Gas Heat

    Gas heating systems offer quick, efficient, and affordable heating, making them a favored option for numerous households. Gas heaters offer several advantages:

    • Quick and effective warming of spaces.
    • Consistent heat output ensures comfort in cold weather.
    • Gas may offer cost advantages over electricity, depending on the area.
    • In areas susceptible to winter storms, gas heaters continue working even during power failures, improving dependability.
    • Compared to certain other heating methods, gas heaters are eco-friendly.
    • Modern gas heaters come equipped with safety measures, ensuring they are a safe heating choice.
    • Installation by professionals is usually simple, and maintenance needs are minimal.

    Disadvantages of Gas Heat

    Gas heaters offer benefits but come with drawbacks:

    • Requires connection to a gas supply, limiting placement options.
    • Combustion releases pollutants, affecting indoor air quality.
    • Initial installation costs are higher than other methods.
    • Fluctuating gas prices affect heating costs.
    • Regular maintenance is crucial for safety and efficiency.

    Gas Heating Vs Electrical Heating

    Gas Heating Vs Electrical Heating
    AI Generated Image: Heaven Gables

    Climate Considerations

    Gas heat is recommended for colder climates where the furnace is essential during chilly months. It requires regular maintenance for safety and durability. Conversely, electric heat suits warmer climates or areas without gas availability, offering longevity and minimal maintenance. An electric heat pump is an efficient choice for exclusive electricity setups, serving as both a heater and an air conditioner.

    Cost Analysis

    Gas heaters may have lower operational costs, but electric heaters typically have cheaper installation and maintenance expenses. Gas heaters generally exhibit higher efficiency levels than electric ones, although safety precautions are necessary due to potentially harmful emissions. Electric heaters, being combustion-free, require only simple plug-in installation, unlike gas heaters that demand a gas supply connection. Maintenance demands differ, with gas furnaces requiring regular professional check-ups compared to electric heaters with lower maintenance requirements.

    Lifespan and Performance

    Electric central heating systems surpass gas boilers' lifespan by up to 50%. Gas furnaces excel in rapid heating and achieving higher temperatures. However, there's a significant consideration for the potential risk of carbon monoxide emissions from gas furnaces, which may increase over time due to component wear and tear.

    Maintenance of the Gas Heating System

    A technician in blue workwear gas heating system
    AI Generated Image: Heaven Gables

    Regular Check-ups

    Regular professional check-ups are crucial. Oil-fired systems require annual tuning and cleaning unless using ultra-low sulfur fuel, while gas-fired systems should be inspected every two years and heat pumps every two to three years. These tune-ups reduce heating costs and extend the system's lifespan, minimize breakdowns, and decrease the emission of pollutants like carbon monoxide and smoke.

    Effective Optimization

    Technicians can assess combustion efficiency through various tests, including flue temperature, carbon dioxide levels, smoke, and carbon monoxide levels. Cleaning, adjustments, and potential modifications can further enhance efficiency and reduce fuel consumption. Additionally, duct sealing, reducing system size, and installing devices like vent dampers and programmable thermostats can yield significant energy savings.

    DIY Modifications

    Simple modifications, such as insulating pipes and ducts and using radiator reflectors, can also improve heat distribution throughout your home, maximizing the effectiveness of your heating system. These DIY enhancements complement professional maintenance efforts and contribute to overall energy efficiency.

    Conclusion

    Gas heating systems provide effective heating options that can lead to substantial savings on energy costs. Moreover, their durability and minimal maintenance needs make them a viable option for extended usage. With technological advancements, modern gas heating systems include improved safety features, providing homeowners with peace of mind.

    FAQs

    How Do I Know if My Heat is Gas or Electric?

    Identifying the energy source of your furnace can be straightforward. A gas furnace is usually connected to a gas supply line, with accompanying meters or pipes nearby. On the other hand, electric furnaces operate solely through your home's electrical grid.

    How Long Does a Gas Water Heater Take to Heat Up?

    A typical 40-gallon water heater can warm up water in approximately 30 to 40 minutes, while a bigger 80-gallon tank usually requires about 60 to 70 minutes to deliver hot water.

    Table of Content

      Get daily updates to your inbox!

      Subscribe to our mailing list to receives daily updates!

      Related Stories