Hip Roof Vs Gable Roof : Deciding what type of roof you want for your home is a significant factor as it affects the appearance of your home and a lot more things. Two of the most popular roof styles nowadays are the hip roof and the gable roof. Both may seem similar but the details make them quite different from each other.
If you need clarification about which one between a hip roof and a gable roof will suit your home, you have landed at the right place. Here you will find everything you need to know about the two styles of roofs including their purposes, differences, and a lot more.
Also Read 17 Types Of Roof Shapes To Add Curb Appeal.
What Is A Hip Roof
The hip roof slopes from the building’s edges and has no straight ends. The hip is the outside angle where two adjacently sloped roof sides meet. The hip bevel describes the size of such an angle. Hip ends refer to the triangular sloped structure created when two hips meet at a roof’s peak.
Hip roofs have their advantages and disadvantages that we have mentioned below to make it easier for you to choose whether you want this type of roof for your home or not.
Pros Of Hip Roofs
High Wind Resistance: Hip roofs are a considerably safer option for areas with strong winds and snowstorms. This is because the structure has an inward slope on its four sides. This contributes to increased resistance to strong wind and precipitation.
Great For Houses With A Low Roof: Hip roofs provide excellent stability and functionality to roofs that have a low slope. Hence, it is the best type of roof for you if you have a house with a low roof.
Visual Appeal: Hip roofs are usually sleeker, more visually appealing, and linked with nicer homes because they are frequently used on higher-end structures.
Cons Of Hip Roofs
Pricey: Hip roofs are usually costly because of their complex design and the materials required. Hence, it can be a problem for people who want to get a roof under a tight budget to get a hip roof because it is not only pricey to install but also to maintain.
Lack Of Attic Space: Because of the two attached slopes of a hip roof, there is not much space left for the attic let alone care for ventilation. So, if you prioritize a spacious attic hip roof will not be the right choice for your home.
Insufficient Ventilation: The equal slopes on both sides makes it difficult to allow proper ventilation in a house with a hip roof. This makes the chances of developing mould and fungus higher around the house.
Know about these Roofing Ideas For The Home Of Your Dreams
What Is A Gable Roof
A roof with two sloping sides and a flat end called a gable is known as a gable roof. There are two empty triangular spots at all ends. Frequently, the walls below them are extended vertically to fill in these openings.
Like two sides of a coin, a gable roof also has its own perks and downfalls. Read ahead to know more about these advantages and disadvantages of the gable roof to get a clear idea of whether it fits your vision of the perfect roof for your home or not.
Pros Of Gable Roofs
Works Great In Snowy Areas: Gable roof is one of the best options when it comes to finding a roof that works great in regard for shedding snow and water. No debris will be collected on the roof hence preventing further damage and maintenance costs.
Proper Ventilation In The Attic: Due to the vaulted ceiling provided by gable roof style, there is plenty of space for the attic and scope for proper ventilation. Hence, this is one of the major advantages that come with the installation of a gable roof.
Cost Effective: Gable roofs are a significantly cheaper option when compared to hip roofs due to their simple design and quicker construction process. Hence, they are a good investment when it comes to roof styles.
Cons Of Gable Roofs
Lower Wind Resistance: For homes in areas that have strong wind resistance, gable roofs are not a wise choice as they don’t perform well there. One of the most common features of gable roofs are the extended rafters positioned at sharp angles to the house’s base. Strong winds may catch below the roof and harm or altogether remove it.
Less Durability: Gable roofs can be a lot less durable than hip roofs especially if they are not installed correctly. Hence, it is essential to know the dangers associated with incorrect roof installation. To maximize its endurance in the face of strong winds, you’ll want to choose a competent roofing business that utilizes the appropriate braces.
Hip Roof Vs Gable Roof
The roof is a crucial part of the home as it is one of the main factors when it comes to protection. Hence, it is essential that you choose the right type of roof for your home to ensure maximum safety and a beautiful appearance of the house.
Hip roof and gable roofs are quite famous and hence people often need clarification when it comes to choosing one amongst the two. To make this choice more accessible for you, we have a detailed comparison mentioned below of the two roof types:
Factors | Hip Roofs | Gable Roofs |
Slope | A hip roof has all of its sides sloping downwards from the top. These slopes are connected under the eaves of the roof. It doesn't have a flat ending or a gable. Church steeples frequently have hip roofs, which are favored for their elevated angle. | A gable roof has two sloping sides and at least one flat end known as a “gable” . It is made of eaves, roof trusses, or fibres and is the most typical roof design in cold or temperate regions. A gable roof's pitch can change significantly. |
Stability | Due to the four slopes in a hip roof instead of two, they are often more sturdy than gable roofs. These roofs are a far superior option for locations with severe winds because they are more durable when compared to gable roofs. | In locations with strong winds, the little droop that gable roofs often have from the face of the house might cause the roof to come off. Gable roofs run the risk of collapse because of their design and structure. |
Attic Space | A hip roof only has a small amount of room left for the attic and ventilation because of the two linked slopes. Therefore, a hip roof would not be a good choice for your home if you value a large attic. | Gable roof provides ample space for an attic and ventilation hence, if it is something non negotiable for you then, this will definitely be the right choice of roof style for your home as compared to a hip roof. This is because there is not even enough space for an attic due to the slope of hip roofs, hence it will not be possible to have a proper attic in a house with a hip roof. |
Maintenance | When it comes to maintenance, hip roofs are the ones that require the most of it. This is because of their complex structure and design. | Gable roofs are frequently more affordable than other roof types because of their basic structure. Due to the high slope and decreased chance of moisture deterioration, the original building cost is lower, and you won't have to worry about ongoing maintenance costs. |
Durability | When it comes to durability, hip roofs take the trophy because they can last for a significantly longer period of time as compared to gable roofs. The reason behind is the multi-sided slope which reduces the possibility of elevation and hence helps the roof stay intact for a longer period of time. | Durability is not the stronges suite of gable roofs and for justified reasons. Gable roofs may be more prone to wind breakage than other roof designs, which could be a problem. |
Costs | Due to the complex design and lengthy construction process of hip roofs, they are relatively costlier than gable roofs. | Gable roofs are significantly cheaper as compared to hip roofs due to their straightforward construction and basic form. Hence, if you want a roof under a budget, gable style roof would definitely be the right choice for your home. |
The Final Takeaway
The optimal sort of roof for your home will rely on a variety of criteria, including a style that meets your tastes, the construction of a new or existing home, the seasonal weather patterns in your area, and your budget.
Since there are pros and cons for both hip and gable roofs, it essentially comes down to personal preference, locality of your home, and its requirements when choosing between the two. Both these roof styles serve different purposes hence you need to decide which one of these fit your needs and preferences.
We hope all your queries and concerns related to hip roof and gable roof along with their comparison got answered here. Remember, home decor and architecture is supposed to be a fun experience for the homeowners so you can take as much creative liberty as you want to make sure that you have the home of your dreams. Happy renovating!
Frequently Asked Questions
Which roof style is most prone to leakage?
Because a flat roof lacks a channel for water to drain off rapidly, moisture can accumulate on the roof’s surface. There are some regions of a flat roof that are more prone to leakage than others on that already thin surface.
What is the simplest style of house roof?
When it comes to simple yet functional roof styles, flat roof takes the trophy without a doubt. This style of roof is very popular among the home decor and styling community and is personal favorite of many homeowners due to its contemporary architectural style and structure. Although these roofs may seem perfectly level, the majority of them have a modest slope that lets rainfall drain.
Which material of roofs is the most durable?
The durability of roof materials not only depends on their strength but also other factors like their ability to resist extreme weather conditions, and more. Slate and clay tiles are two of the most long-lasting roofing options, these materials are costlier than the other available options but they prove their worth by lasting a very long time.
Here are 9 Types Of Roofing You Should Consider
Do gable roofs outrank flat roofs?
Flat roofs are more prone to water infiltration and debris accumulation, which, if neglected, can result in structural damage. A gable roof’s enhanced drainage makes it more resilient to falling debris like leaves and more durable in times of severe rain.
Which type of roof is the safest?
Some types of roofing materials are significantly more wind-resistant than others. Metal panels, asphalt shingles, and concrete tiles are the three roofing materials that withstand strong winds the best. Due to the way that metal panels interlock and overlap when linked to their metal roof underlayment, they provide great wind protection.
