Shingles vs Metal Roof Cost | Compare Expenses, Characteristics, And Styles

Author Image

By George Taylor

Updated: Jan 25, 2024

8 min read

shingles vs metal roof cost

Table of Content

    Asphalt shingles and metal roofs are quite common among homeowners and have their different pros and cons. If you need clarification on these two types of roofs and want to choose the right one for your home, then you have landed at the right place. Here we have researched shingles and metal roof costs, advantages, disadvantages, and many more defining factors so you don’t have to. So, let’s dive into home decor and furnishing to help you choose the right type of roof for your home.

    Factors Affecting the Cost Of Shingles And Metal Roofs

    Also Read: Metal Roof Over Shingles Problems

    Material Composition and Quality

    Material Composition of Shingles and Metal Roofs

    There is a range in shingle quality; higher-grade shingles are usually more expensive but may also have better warranties and longevity. Asphalt shingles come in a variety of forms, the most popular of which are architectural or three-tab shingles. Specialty or premium shingles will set you back more than regular ones.

    The selection of metal materials, including copper, zinc, steel, or aluminum, can have a big impact on price.

    Roof Dimensions and Detailing

    The larger are covered with shingles or metal panels, the higher will be the cost of material and installation. Hence, the roof dimensions directly affect the costs. Also, the type of design or detailing you want the roof to alter the amount you will have to spend on it. For example, if you want a steeper roof, then it will be more expensive in terms of labor because of the risk factor and hence, the need to increase safety precautions.

    Lifespan Of The Roof

    The initial expenses might be significantly impacted by the material’s lifespan. Because metal roofs are more long-lasting, energy-efficient, and environmentally friendly than shingle roofs, their initial cost is higher. Although shingle roofs are less expensive initially, they are less energy-efficient and have a shorter lifespan than metal roofs.


    The unique qualities of each type of roofing material mean that maintenance for metal and shingle roofs is different. To ensure optimal performance and longevity, regular maintenance is beneficial for both metal and shingle roofs. Preventing expensive problems mostly requires routine inspections and timely repairs, which can eventually add to the overall cost of the roof.

    Cost Comparison: Shingles vs. Metal Roofing

    Type Of Cost Shingles  Metal Roofing 
    Average Cost Per Sq.Foot $3-$5 $5-$16
    Highest Cost  $12,000 $68,000
    Lowest Cost  $5,500 $8,500

    Metal Roofing : For a roof that is 1,700 square feet, installing metal roofing typically costs $13,200. It’s important to keep in mind that materials often represent over two-thirds of the total cost. Labor prices can vary from $2 to $14 per square foot, while the cost of metal roofing supplies can range from $1 to $25 per square foot.

    Shingles :  A bundle of roofing shingles typically takes up 33.3 square feet. Therefore, three bundles make up one roofing square. Notably, the choice of material will affect the cost per square foot. For $3–$5 per square foot during construction, an asphalt shingle roof is reasonably priced, perfect for moderate climates, low maintenance, and long-lasting—it can last for 15 to 30 years.

    Advantages Of Shingles And Metal Roofing


    • In many cases, asphalt shingles are the most cost-effective choice for roofing projects.
    • Compared to big slabs of metal roofing or heavy tile roofing, asphalt shingles are often easier to handle and can be placed swiftly and easily by someone with roofing knowledge.
    • Particularly in coastal regions where it is exposed to saltwater, metal roofing is susceptible to rusting. Thankfully, shingles made of asphalt never rust or corrode.

    Metal Roof Panels

    • Metal roofs have a long lifespan of 40–70 years.
    • They provide better defense against ice dams and heavy snowfall in colder regions.
    • Gorgeous designs that go with every neighborhood or house.
    • Panels that interlock to provide optimal wind resistance.Metal roofs are more resilient than shingles in severe wind conditions in regions with harsh weather.

    Shop For Metal Roof Panels From Trusted Stores In The US

    1. Home Depot

    You can get everything you need at Home Depot, from the necessary components to secure your property to the colors that will give your roof the style you want. Their installation services will assist you in completing the task correctly from beginning to end.

    2. Lowe’s

    Your home’s roof shields you from the elements, but when choosing the material for your roof, you should also take efficiency and beauty into account. Roofing panels are an excellent substitute for typical asphalt shingles, regardless of whether you require a new roof for your house or a storage shed. You can get everything at Lowe’s to protect and beautify your home and other structures, including polycarbonate, asphalt roof panels, and metal roofing.

    3. Bridger Steel

    When beginning your search and gaining a better understanding of the many metal roofing panel systems accessible in today’s designs, Bridger Steel offers a variety of metal roof panels to take into consideration.

    Also Read: The Best 6 Shingles For Roofing Ideas To Inspire You!

    Buy Shingles From Trusted Stores Across The US

    1. Home Depot

    All the supplies you need to install roof shingles expertly are available at The Home Depot. View our extensive selection of shingle colors and styles to find something that will suit both your taste and budget.

    2. Owen’s Corning

    Browse Owens Corning’s roofing shingles by style, color, and performance qualities, such as wind resistance and warranty coverage, to select the ideal roof for your house.

    The Final Takeaway

    A key factor to consider when choosing between metal and shingle roofs is the cost. Although they come in a variety of shapes and colors, shingles are an economical alternative that requires more frequent maintenance due to their shorter lifespan. Conversely, metal roofs are more expensive initially but are renowned for their resilience, longevity, and low maintenance needs.

    Metal roofs are an appealing choice for homeowners looking for a long-term investment, exceptional durability, and contemporary looks, while shingle roofs can be a great option for people with limited funds and a preference for conventional styles.


    Is It Cheaper to Put a Metal Roof or Shingles?

    From an initial cost perspective, the metal roofing will be more costly.

    Do You Need Roof Vents With a Metal Roof?

    A metal roof can get quite hot, in which case an effective ventilation system will help keep heat out of the attic. Ventilation is crucial because, on a bright day, when your roof gets hot, your attic will also get warmer. Furthermore, your house or place of business will get hotter as the attic gets hotter.

    Do Shingles or Metal Roofs Last Longer?

    Shingles usually break down between two and four times faster than metal roofing. The thought of purchasing one extra roof rather than several is appealing to homeowners. When it comes to hail and other extreme weather conditions, metal roofing performs better than shingles.

    Does a Metal Roof Increase the Value of Your House?

    The best roofing material, metal, can raise the value of your house. The return on investment for residential roofing projects that include replacing a metal roof is close to 50%. According to Allied Market Research, metal roofing is becoming more and more popular as a result of the numerous advantages that metal offers.

    Table of Content

      Get daily updates to your inbox!

      Subscribe to our mailing list to receives daily updates!

      Related Stories